The Lost Boys
92%
6.5k ratings
A Santa Carla boardwalk, a gang of vampires who double as a rock band, and a score from The Rescues with real bite. The cast album is nominated for Best Musical Theater Album at the 2027 Grammys. Michael Arden stages this take on the 1987 Warner Bros. cult film at the Palace, where Shoshana Bean and Ali Louis Bourzgui both won 2026 Tonys for their performances. Play it loud on the walk home.
Schmigadoon!
3.6k ratings
Cinco Paul's score already won the 2026 Tony, and the cast album is nominated for Best Musical Theater Album at the 2027 Grammys. Two New York doctors wander into a town straight out of Brigadoon and The Music Man, and can't leave until they find true love. Cue "Corn Puddin'," "You Can't Tame Me" and a full NYC dream ballet. Catch the references or don't; the tunes stick either way.
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
93%
4.1k ratings
Two actors, one score, and a 2027 Grammy nomination for Best Musical Theater Album. Jim Barne and Kit Buchan's two-hander follows Dougal, a chipper Brit in town for his dad's wedding, and Robin, a no-nonsense New Yorker with errands to run, across 48 hours and most of the boroughs. Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts sing every note between them, so the album plays like one long conversation. The Longacre run ends November 29.
Chicago
86%
9.5k ratings
The Kander and Ebb jazz score that gave us "All That Jazz," "Cell Block Tango," "Razzle Dazzle," and "When You're Good to Mama." Running at the Ambassador since 1996, the revival keeps Bob Fosse's choreographic vocabulary front and center. The kind of cast album that you and your mother both have on Spotify.
The Book of Mormon
91%
17.6k ratings
The score that defined a decade of musical theater, from South Park's Trey Parker and Matt Stone with Frozen's Bobby Lopez. "Hello!" became the universal earworm, "I Believe" the karaoke flex, "Turn It Off" the inside joke at every afterparty. Fifteen years in, the cast album still earns its place in heavy rotation.
Buena Vista Social Club
96%
6.2k ratings
The music that captured the world’s heart is officially a 2026 Grammy-winner for Best Musical Theatre Album. This production reimagines an iconic, soul-stirring sound with an electrifying new energy, offering a masterclass in rhythm and storytelling that sounds just as incredible on your headphones as it does from the front row.
Maybe Happy Ending
95%
5.9k ratings
A 2026 Grammy nomination is just the latest accolade for this uniquely poetic production. Celebrated for its lush, melodic score and 'Helperbot' protagonists, it’s a refreshing departure from the typical Broadway sound—a true soundtrack obsession for the modern romantic.
The Outsiders
4.9k ratings
A 2025 Grammy nominee for Best Musical Theater Album, this gritty and powerful production is the emotional gut-punch of the year. Its raw, cinematic score creates a modern soundscape so hauntingly right, you’ll be streaming the tracks the moment you walk out of the theater.
Hadestown
8k ratings
2020 Grammy winner for Best Musical Theater Album, this folk-and-jazz-infused epic has journeyed from a cult concept album to a global sensation. Its hauntingly powerful score reimagines the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice through soul-stirring songs that have captured the hearts—and the playlists—of fans everywhere.
Hamilton
16.3k ratings
Few albums have defined an era like this 2016 Grammy winner for Best Musical Theater Album. A masterclass in lyrical genius from Lin-Manuel Miranda, this innovative epic remains a global phenomenon—holding its crown as the most-streamed cast recording of the year for fans who can’t get enough of its non-stop brilliance.
Wicked
94%
27.4k ratings
The soaring ballads of this 2005 Grammy winner for Best Musical Theater Album have truly defined a generation. As one of the most iconic scores in Broadway history, its powerhouse vocals and gravity-defying melodies do more than just top the charts—they leave a permanent handprint on your heart.
The Lion King
15.2k ratings
Experience the legendary sound that earned the 1999 Grammy for Best Musical Show Album. From the soul-stirring 'Circle of Life' to the iconic collaborations of Elton John and Tim Rice, this score remains a cornerstone of Broadway history—delivering an emotional power that has captivated listeners for over a quarter-century.
& Juliet
12.2k ratings
This vibrant musical rewrites Juliet's story as she imagines life after Romeo and belts Britney Spears and Kelly Clarkson anthems. With an infectious, high-energy score packed with pop perfection from Grammy-winning producer Max Martin, this larger-than-life production is the ultimate crowd-pleaser.
MJ The Musical
4.8k ratings
This electrifying musical delivers a high-octane celebration of the King of Pop, charting his evolution into a cultural icon. With over 25 of his greatest hits packed into one explosive show, every number is performed with an energy that makes the theatre feel like a sold-out stadium concert.
SIX
89%
5.3k ratings
Henry VIII’s six ex-wives hit the stage, reimagined as a fiercely modern pop group ready to tell their side of Herstory. With catchy hooks and powerhouse vocals, this album of empowerment anthems has been streamed over one billion times by loyal fans around the world.