Close Sidebar
This show closed on April 7, 2019

About The Other Josh Cohen

From the moment you walk into the Westside Theatre, you’re immersed in the quirky world of Josh’s NYC apartment… as it is getting robbed. Thus begins this hilarious rock-and-roll romantic comedy about good guy Josh caught in a lifelong battle with bad luck. But just when all hope seems lost, a mysterious letter arrives that changes his life forever. A cast of mind-blowing actor-musicians leap in and out of the story playing almost as many parts as they do instruments. “It’s Seinfeld meets Rodgers & Hart,” raves one in an endless string of love letter reviews. This funny, touching, hummable new musical makes its triumphant return, hailed by Jesse Green of The NY Times as “the spontaneously charming musical that is just right for right now.” The Other Josh Cohen is a 90-minute life-changing laughfest for the whole family that will leave you feeling better about the world.

Tell Me More

A lot can happen in a year. At least that’s case for down-on-his luck Josh Cohen. Not only is he single and slumming it, but just a few days before Valentine’s Day, he was robbed and left with only one Neil Diamond CD in his run-down digs. His luck changes, however, when he receives a massive check in the mail made out to “Josh Cohen,” though he may not be the intended recipient. Regardless, the newfound fortune — whether Josh cashes the check or not — does him well, as evidenced by “Narrator Josh,” his future, slimmed-down self who tells the story of how he found a happy ending — for the most part.

Written by longtime friends David Rossmer and Steve Rosen and directed by Hunter Foster, “The Other Josh Cohen,” stars its writers in the title role — Rosen as the unlucky schlub with an unbecoming stache, and Rossmer as the rejuvenated guitar rocker.

Read more

What To Watch For

  • Writers and stars David Rossmer and Steve Rosen met as teenagers, when they attended French Woods Festival of the Performing Arts together.
  • Rossmer and Rosen have spent eight years working on “The Other Josh Cohen,” which made its New York debut in 2010, under the title “V-Day,” at the New York Musical Theater Festival. It later played the SoHo Playhouse, New Jersey’s Paper Mill Playhouse, and the Geva Theater Center in Rochester.
  • In its initial Off-Broadway run at SoHo Playhouse, “The Other Josh Cohen” was nominated for six Drama Desk Awards and the Lortel Award for Outstanding Musical.
  • Rossmer and Rosen wrote the initial draft of what became “The Other Josh Cohen” in a matter of months.
  • Takeout food menus take credit for some of the show’s lyrics. “‘Samuel Cohen’s Family Tree’ was [inspired by] a menu for a Korean barbecue restaurant,” Rosen reveals. The restaurant is Annie’s Korean Barbecue.

Read more

Run Time

90 minutes, no intermission

Start Date

End Date



A pop rock musical charmer, The Other Josh Cohen is VERY FUNNY, VERY TUNEFUL & VERY UPLIFTING!
Broadway World
Fabulously feel-good funny show that shouldn't be missed. A Triumph!
DC Metro Theater Arts

Westside Theatre Downstairs

407 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036

The Other Josh Cohen tickets on TodayTix

Tickets are not currently available. Set an alert and we’ll tell you when more tickets go on sale.