Log in
Sign up
Open SidebarMENU
Log in
Sign up
This show closed on October 28, 2019

About I Put A Spell On You: The Return of the Sanderson Sisters

The Sanderson Sisters are back from the dead, and no one wants to miss their return! Jay Armstrong Johnson, Emily Cates, and Danny Marin are proud to share this cast of kooky characters BACK by popular demand after three years of SOLD OUT shows. Come Little Children and celebrate Halloween Salem Style! Expect a bigger, better, and bolder new show with a rockin’ band, show-stopping choreography and amazing surprise guests! Previous guest stars have included Krysta Rodriguez (SMASH), Andy Mientus (SMASH), Ahmad Simmons (Hadestown), Major Attaway (Aladdin) and more. This is one HALLOWEEN event you won’t want to miss.

6:00pm doors | 7:00pm show


Table seating is reserved exclusively for ticket holders who purchase seated tickets. By purchasing a seated ticket you agree to also purchase a minimum of two food and/or beverage items per person. Table seating is first come, first seated. Tables are communal so you may be seated with other patrons.

A standing room area is available by the bar for all guests who purchase “Standing Room” tickets. Food and beverage can be purchased at the bar but there is no minimum purchase required in this area.

Start Date

End Date



(Le) Poisson Rouge

158 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10012

I Put A Spell On You: The Return of the Sanderson Sisters tickets on TodayTix

Tickets are not currently available. Set an alert and we’ll tell you when more tickets go on sale.