Close Sidebar

Critics' Picks

Check out the shows The New York Times has raved about.

These top-rated Broadway shows and off-Broadway shows have earned the coveted title of "Critics' Pick" from the New York Times.


"It may not be typical theater, but this immersive show is pulse-pounding and intensely affecting." -Laura Collins-Hughes


"...promises company and conversation" - Laura Collins-Hughes

John Lithgow: Stories By Heart

"...a touching tribute" - Jesse Green

Disco Pigs

"A harrowing, exhilarating revival" - Ben Brantley

Farinelli and the King

"...shimmering fairy tale for grown-ups." - Ben Brantley

Once On This Island

"A big, bold delight." - Jesse Green

Bright Colors And Bold Patterns

"Drew Droege...makes for hilarious company in this one-person show." -Charles Isherwood

The Band's Visit

"This singularly seductive show...finds the ecstasy in ennui in a small desert town" -Ben Brantley

The Book of Mormon

“This was my fourth time and they still had me at ‘hello’”- Ben Brantley

A Bronx Tale

"The musical-theater equivalent of that classic comfort food." - Charles Isherwood

Drunk Shakespeare

"In its outlandish way, it’s as carefully thought out and executed as any real 'Macbeth.'" - Neil Genzlinger

School of Rock

"A Lloyd Webber show that only wants to have fun and hopes that you do, too." - Ben Brantley